Reality singing shows have been a cornerstone of Indian television for decades. But lately, many viewers and industry insiders feel these programmes have drifted from their original purpose: finding and nurturing musical talent. Instead, emotional backstories, dramatic edits and TRP-driven twists often take centre stage.
Why audiences are fed up
There’s no denying reality TV brings excitement and huge audiences. Still, the same elements that hook viewers can also backfire. Short audition clips, dramatic music, tearful reunions and manufactured rivalries create powerful TV — but they don’t always showcase who can actually sing.
- Editing and storytelling: Producers often shape contestants’ journeys to create a narrative, sometimes overshadowing pure performance.
- TRP pressure: High ratings can push shows to prioritise sensational moments rather than musical excellence.
- Popularity wins: Public voting and fan bases can let technically weaker performers advance over more talented singers.
Abhijeet Ghoshal’s perspective
Abhijeet Ghoshal, a renowned Bollywood playback singer and winner of 11 seasons of the hit reality show, has been vocal about these changes. He argues that when reality shows prioritise emotional storytelling and television moments, they risk losing credibility as talent platforms.
According to voices like his, the industry should return to basics: put the microphone and the song first, give contestants room to grow musically, and let mentoring matter more than manufactured drama. He stresses that true artists need long-term support — not just a dramatic episode or viral clip.
Where the format tends to fail contestants
- Short-term exposure: A viral performance can bring attention, but it doesn’t guarantee a sustainable music career.
- Over-coaching for TV: Coaching that focuses on visual appeal or emotional delivery may ignore vocal technique and musicality.
- One-dimensional judging: Judges sometimes play characters for TV — the harsh critic, the loving mentor — which can distort honest feedback.
Small fixes that could make a big difference
- Prioritise live performances: More unscripted live shows would reveal who thrives under pressure.
- Transparent scoring: Clearer criteria combining expert scores and audience votes would balance popularity with skill.
- Long-term mentorship: Structured guidance from industry professionals, even after the show, would help contestants build careers.
- Focus on original music: Encouraging contestants to perform or write original songs can shift the spotlight from TV moments to artistry.
- Less manufactured drama: Let contestants’ talent drive the narrative rather than creating artificial conflicts.
The role of viewers and the industry
Change won’t happen overnight. Viewers can influence content by rewarding substance — sharing performances that highlight technique, streaming contestants’ music, and supporting honest critique. Producers and networks can listen to industry veterans like Abhijeet Ghoshal and redesign formats that invest in artists, not just episodes.
Digital platforms offer hope
Streaming services and social media give talented singers alternative pathways. Independent releases, YouTube performances and virtual concerts allow artists to reach audiences without depending solely on television formats. If reality shows evolve to complement these options rather than mimic them, the comeback is possible.
Reality singing shows still have the power to launch careers. With some clear-sighted reforms, less manufactured drama and more mentorship, they can return to being true incubators of musical talent — something both viewers and industry veterans would welcome.